Did you know there are many different styles of picking techniques? The techniques help you in certain scenarios, depending what you want to play. the way you pick individual strings.
What’s The Difference Between Economy Picking & Alternative Picking? Economy picking helps you when changing strings as the direction your hand is always moving at the same motion of picking hand. Whilst it alternative picking always goes up, down, up, down.
To really understand the difference you need to understand the mechanics behind both. In this article we discuss this in grave detail.
1. What is Alternate Picking?
Alternate picking is not the only picking technique available, but it is a basic technique we all must learn.
Alternate picking is a guitar technique that involves continuously alternating between downward and upward strokes when picking. Good alternate picking requires that you do not deviate from a steady down-up or up-down motion of the picking hand.
Many beginner guitarists, as well as some intermediate musicians, have the unfortunate habit of just employing down-strokes to all their riffs and this can be limiting for speed. By alternating between up and down strokes you have twice the speed in comparison. However, speed is actually at a slight disadvantage when comparing it to economy picking. See below…
Advantages (as compared to economy picking):
- It easier to employ – being easier to employ is a big point to stress and is probably the main reason why you would choose alternate picking as the concept is simpler to understand as you are always picking up and down in sequence.
- No forward planning – this is also a big point to consider. Because everything is picking in a up/down sequence you do not need to do any forward planning.
- Better for creativity – when employing economy picking there is a lot of forward planning involved. This can be a creativity killer! You can spend to much time and energy planning your picking sequence rather than just getting in the vibe.
- Its more practical – Its easier for jamming purposes as it does not require forward planning you can be more spontaneous
To more intermediate musicians the few alternate picking advantages outweigh the disadvantages.
Disadvantages (as compared to economy picking):
- Accuracy & Flexibility – harder to change strings on an odd picking pattern as you need to utilize outside picking (discussed in section 3). You can only change strings in even patterns unless you will find your self employing outside picking technique which can be very trouble some for beginner to intermediate and even more advanced guitarists
- Control & bad habits – people that learn this technique often build bad habits as it common to tremolo pick everything. People that do this will not properly synchronize the picking with fretting hand
- Conserve Energy – if we decide to alternate pick in odd sequence then we use more energy as we employ outside picking
- Speed – employs both inside picking and outside picking. the distance to travel with outside picking is longer
The main problem we face when comparing alternate picking is that if we pick in odd sequence then we employ outside picking.
Below we discuss how economy picking attempts to solve this problem…
2. What is Economy Picking?
Economy picking or what we also call ‘speed picking’ is an extention to alternate picking. The principle is that all your movements during the picking procress will be as economical as possible, whereby no movements are irrelevant.
It still involves alternating between up and down picking stokes. However, what makes it different is that if you change string on an odd sequence, you would sweep to the next string. With economy picking, it’s all about using one continuous pick motion to cross your guitar strings.
For economy picking, for example, if you start on a downstroke and play three notes on the A string, you should end your picking motions on a downstroke for the third note. So there’s only one sweeping movement towards one direction, either it’s a downstroke or an upstroke.
Advantages (as compared to alternate picking):
- Speed – First thing first, economy picking, as we’ve mentioned, is among the most economical ways to carry out the picking on your guitar, so there is no place for ineffective or irrelevant motion.
- less effort to employ – once you have good technique you can play faster and it feel less effort as compared to alternate picking
Disadvantages (as compared to alternate picking):
- Forward Planning – In order to accomplish this, in advance, you need to plan out all the motions you need for your picking applying this economy picking. And the notes you would prefer to play on each of the strings you play by the fretting hand will also need to be planned all in your head ahead.
unnecessary motions, switching among them and then wasting the motions and your time.
3. Directional Picking
To understand the difference between Alternative Picking and Economy Picking you first need to understand directional picking. The pivoting point that distinguishes both alternate and economy picking is the motion of the picking hand when swapping strings. This concept is called directional picking.
What is directional picking?
The basic idea of directional choosing is to take the quickest route to the next note you need to play. To understand this more we need to look in more detail about inside picking and outside picking.
‘Inside picking’ is literally describing its function through its name. you pick the same direction in which you are travelling. For example if you are moving down from Low E to high E then when you change string all the picking needs to be downwards.
outside picking is when you pick the outside of the string apposed to the motion you are travelling.
Outside picking is a guitar picking technique in which the lower of the two strings is picked with downstrokes and the higher string is picked with upstrokes (lower refers to “closer to the floor” rather than lower in pitch; the B string is lower than the G string on a standard-tuned guitar in this regard). After the note is plucked, the pick ends up “outside” the space between the picked strings, thus the name of the method. For example, if you use downstrokes on the G string and upstrokes on the D string while playing the D and G strings on a guitar, the pick will end up “outside” the D and G strings.
To sum up, when running through scales the BEST approach is always inside picking.
Alternate picking is sometimes the quickest way reach the next note. Other times, the quickest way to change strings is to use sweep picking rather than alternate picking. When these mechanisms are combined, maximum guitar speed and efficiency are achieved with the least amount of effort.
4. Alternate picking & Directional Picking
The basic premise of tight alternate picking is to always alternate your pick strokes… Even if it compels your hand to perform greater and inefficient motions as a result when running the scale in odd sequence. To acquire the same level of guitar speed, you must work considerably work harder (and practice much longer) when learning how to change between strings in an odd sequence.
When you play an even number of notes per string, you will always follow inside picking mechanism.
5. Economy picking & Directional Picking
Economy picking always employs inside picking only.
During the sweep picking to change between the strings, as the usual practice, you will move your fretting hand towards only one direction, for example, if it’s a downstroke then it will be continuing down that direction. So with the directional picking technique, it will be the same as the very first sweep picking step, but you need to repeat that motion non-stopping, with a new downstroke every time.
For the guitar pick, you need to let it fall slightly onto the next string during the sweep picking process. Take an example of the three notes, the moment when you reach the third note, the guitar pick can then fall into the next strings, approaching it in the slightest way and pushing against it.
Now after a few times practicing on how to perform this motion correctly and in the most comfortable way. You will then try to repeat that same motion of the guitar pick resting on every single string during the process of sweep picking.
6. When to use Outside Picking
This whole article has been basically slating outside picking. However, it is also important to add if outside picking has its place?
I tend to use outside picking when i riff more death metal type riffs as this creates high attack between hitting the single notes between riff on the low E string.
Although not all guitarists are as preoccupied with speed as others, the vast majority of guitarists will use it at least some of the time. Control is important regardless of how fast or slow you play.
Regardless of genre, alternate picking is vital even with its flaws. However, economy picking can be utilised to make life easier. But in the end, both techniques are important as they both support you in different ways.